I'm still on the hunt for the perfect mary janes to wear with my new Chanel two-tone tights. I haven't totally ruled out getting the Chanel pair from the show but I'm sure I can find a good substitute for the black pair. It might be harder to find another version of the tan and black pair and I like them both so much.
I have a few pairs of black mary janes but not with this same balance of chunky heel and strap. But I think this pair by Façade is the closest I've found so far. They're all patent so you dont have the textural contrast or the rounded buckle flap detail but you have the similar height and heel and shape.
These are sure to be far more affordable, at just over $100. I'm going to try and be patient and see what happens with the Chanel shoes. But I need to decide soon so I can wear my yummy new tights. I want it to cool off so I can break them out!