Tribute or Desperate Attempt?

So here is one of 2007's "It" shoes - the YSL Tribute platform. Personally I thought is was only okay and while I like the white heel, I thought the platform was ridiculous. No matter how many stars wore it. I much preferred the non-platform slingback which is what I got.



So when I see this new version of this shoe I just think it is a sad desperate attempt to try and recapture that top spot status again this year.



I mean, I know they will be popular because they're flashy and all but they really are not attractive.



Would you wear these if the price were not a barrier (they're $690 at Saks)?

By the way, there is also a woven leather version for $760, if you are so inclined.